Navigating Identity, Legitimacy, and Stigma

“If we allow ourselves to think there’s one entrepreneurial identity, that excludes from consideration important other identities like faith and religious-based identities. And I think that theoretical mistake has kept us from seeing what’s really right in our face.” – Dr. Ted Baker

A panel from the 2025 L.I.F.E. Research Conference featured presentations on the topics of identity, legitimacy, and stigma. This panel featured four distinguished guests: Drs. Glen Kreiner, Caroline Essers, Elco van Burg, and Ted Baker.

Key insights from each speaker covered a large amount of territory:

• Glen Kreiner explored mental health stigma, breaking it down into subsets of structural, social/public, and self-stigma. He emphasized the prevalence of mental health issues and the unique challenges faced by entrepreneurs [0:56].
• Caroline Essers examined the intersectionality of gender, ethnicity, and religion in female entrepreneurship, particularly among Muslim women in the Netherlands. Her research highlighted the “identity work” these entrepreneurs undertake to establish legitimacy [10:12].
• Elco van Burg discussed the practices of caring for humans, drawing from studies in various contexts, including faith-based organizations. He noted the resourcefulness of religious organizations and the potential “dark side” of calling in volunteer settings [18:04].
• Ted Baker addressed the intersection of religious and capitalist identities, particularly in African contexts. He introduced the concept of “identity congruence” and provided compelling examples of how individuals navigate multiple identities [27:56].

Action Steps for College Teachers:

1. Promote the mental health continuum: Integrate the concept into your teaching to normalize mental health challenges and foster open discussion [8:04].
2. Encourage critical thinking on identity: Challenge the notion of a single “entrepreneurial identity” and prompt students to consider how multiple identities intersect [41:01].

Action Steps for Entrepreneurs:

1. Proactively create inclusive policies: Develop HR policies and a culture that supports employee mental health, aiming to destigmatize such issues [6:44].
2. Leverage faith for identity congruence: Explore ways to integrate your religious beliefs into your business practices to foster a meaningful sense of purpose and guide ethical decision-making [32:09, 33:54].

Want to stay informed about the latest research and insights from L.I.F.E.?

Subscribe to our quarterly email newsletter